Had season tickets for the Rangers for 15 years in the 80s and 90s and always came in from Jersey weather driving or on the train but before each game always got a couple slices and stood at the counter or sat at the counter. Great pizza.

If I'm in the city and in Penn Station I always make it a point to stop here and grab a slice. I enjoy their Pizza enough to stop every time.. it's good NYC style Pizza. Staff is nice and quick as well!

OK, OK, OK. Somebody has to speak up about Don Pepi's OTHER offerings. While there trying to decipher the pizza choices 8 or 9 years ago, I overheard some one order a ham and cheese ... no, make that 'brie,' sandwich on pump with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. I stepped back to watch the production. Production it was, like a ballet. About 2 minutes later it appeared on the counter...MONSTAH! Heck with pizza, I'll have one of those! Paired with a cold beer it's the perfect train companion for the trip back up to Bastoon. We have made it our go-to ever since...not one regret. Going North or South...we always make time to hit Pepi's...SO New York. SO glad. Someday we'll break down and try the pizza.

Their pizza is so good. It's located right in Penn Station. Whenever I hit the city, I am sure to stop here on my way home even if I'm not hungry. I'll eat it the next day and throw it in the air fryer. No place to sit but the pizza is phenomenal.

I always grab a slice or two here when I come through Penn Station. The guys who work here are friendly and service is super duper fast. It's fairly representative of NYC pizza, with a crispy-chewy crust that's neither too thin nor too thick/doughy, nice sauce, good amount of cheese, and plenty of toppings. If this is the first NY slice you experience when you step off the train, you could do a lot worse. I usually get a combo slice of sorts which costs $6 including tax. A bit expensive but that's transit hub pricing for ya.

Grabbed a couple of slices before hitting the train to New Jersey. Got a square and a round slice both were good. You pick them what you want from a pan they take them and reheat them in the oven. Super thin the way I like them. Sauce was good not to sweet. Had Coke which is a good thing.

I kid you not, some of the best pizza that I've had in NYC was from Don Pepsi's in PENN STATION! Even some friends who live in the city admit that they descend down past the gates of hell on occasion to enjoy a DP slice. Slices are big, hot, cheesy and crunchy and they don't skimp on the toppings. My favorite is the sausage, so good! Give them a try.

I saw this place as I was walking and it smelled so good so we stopped and I am glad we did. It was the best slice of cheese pizza I have ever had. It was prefect. The crust wasn't too thin which I liked. The only thing was there was not a big seating area so this was more of a grab and go spot but I didn't mind. Definitely recommend!